Palantir Quest (1994) – tunnel vision (review part I)

I’ve been rummaging through my collection of (twenty-something) I.C.E. middle-earth books lately. I could get good money for them – last time I checked Palantir Quest in particular was on sale for 175 usd on ebay despite being in terrible condition (mine isn’t much better!). But y’know, I’m quite sentimental about these, they are the first rpgs books I’ve bought, some thirty years ago, at age fourteen-fifteen with my hard-earned money as a field hand at the time.

So, no selling.

Paid for in sweat and sore knees.

Palantir Quest is in fact an unusual one among this collection as being one of the rare Adventures book along with Kin-Strife, as well as several much slimmer adventures compilations. All the others in the line are sourcebooks, as far as I know. Incredibly detailed and well-researched sourcebooks I must add in case you haven’t heard of them, something that doesn’t exist anymore in rpgs I think, that required an entire team of dedicated people to do. Something to be nostalgic about no doubt. Keep that in mind if you please, because I’ll be a bit harsh with this one: I.C.E’s sourcebooks were absolutely great.

But back to our current subject.

From the book’s back cover: « Strange portents in the great Seeing-stone of Minas Tirith give promise that one of the lost palantiri of the North has returned to the lands of Men. Can the adventurers find this legendary treasure and bring it to King Elessar? Rogues of the wilds, blizzards out of the Forodwaith, and the greed in Men’s hearts all conspire against them. »

Adventuring into Middle-Earth’s 4th Age

The premise is quite interesting, unlike most of what has been published by I.C.E. this adventure takes place some years AFTER the events of the Lord of the Rings. Sauron has been permanently defeated, what remains of his forces has been scattered away and Aragorn, as the ruler of both Gondor and Arnor is now known as King Elessar. This is the begininng of a new era, the 4th Age of Middle-Earth, and what better news to go with this time of triumphant joy than the resurfacing of a long-lost palantir that could help unite both halves, North and South, of this new victorious kingdom?

Elon: « Imagine holding this super heavy bowling ball in your hands, straining your mind in a superhuman effort, and talk to ONE other person in the world … »

Yes, thank you Elon, very impressive.

But you need two palantiri to do that.

Aragorn/King Elessar has the one from Orthanc of course and the one that Sauron had has been destroyed (or is lost, buried under the ruins of Barad-Dur presumably) and Minas Tirith’s palantir (this book says) has been unfortunately imprinted by Denethor’s last moments of agony (a rather unpleasant sight to behold), this is why finding this other palantir would be incredibly useful.

Enter the PCs.

(Side note: Suggested starting level is 4, the PCs are presumed to have some prior accomplishments. There’s also a provided list of pre-made characters as well as suggested eventual replacement, one for each chapter.)

They’ve been convoked to Minas Tirith by NPC Tarquillan, the venerable Royal Seer, to do the king’s bidding and find the lost palantir of the North. Or not exactly that way – they’re told that a spell from a tome called « A Treatise on Subtle Magika » has been discovered to exist and (much faith has been put into that it seems) it could be used to locate the palantir that has only been glimpsed at. (a written spell? a bit peculiar to me thematically speaking but okay, let’s get on with it). The most likely location of the tome is in the Royal Library of the ruined city of Annuminas.

Unbeknownst to the PCs and their employer, Taladhan, a powerful evil magician no one has ever heard of (he apparently hasn’t got the memo that evil has been defeated) who’s scheming from his hideout in faraway Greenwood, knows everything about the plan to recover the palantir because the Royal Seer’s assistant in fact spies for him. Very astute of him to have put a spy there I must say, just in case there would specifically be news from a resurfacing palantir. But anyway.

Thus begins one of the most Tangential Fetch Quest in the history of RPGs. Probably.

Part II

4 commentaires sur “Palantir Quest (1994) – tunnel vision (review part I)

  1. Sounds a bit less of an epic adventure in Middle-Earth that I had envisioned all these years ever since I saw that title in a gaming magazine. We tried playing MERP as kids and I can second that opinion about sourcebooks, that one about peoples of Middle-Earth read like somebody hit Grandpa Tolkien over the head and stole his notes for an unpublished appendix to Lord of the Rings. Too bad the game itself was one of the most confused licensed games I can think of. I mean, you could still play it without fireballs flying in every direction and a critical hit effects list you could teach ER doctors from, but it still begged the question why that stuff there, innit?

    Aimé par 1 personne

    • It is epic in scope in a sense, maybe, but not much else. If I talk a bit more about it in part 2, you’ll see that the PCs go all over the map in one big railroad of an adventure. With the bad guys always one step ahead whatever the PCs do, until they reach the pre-written finale…

      As for the game system, it wasn’t bad I think, but yes you’re right, it was a really bad fit for middle-earth.

      Aimé par 1 personne

Répondre à Palantir Quest (1994) – dungeon à la sauce Rolemaster (review part III) | Streets & Spores Annuler la réponse.